Kid came home this week w/ two invitations for the birthday parties of her year mates (one in her class, the other in one of the other 7 first grade classes). I thought the extreme difference in the two invites was notable.
The first instructed all the guests to dress in their best “princess dress” (I am still not sure what that even means, really, we don’t have something “princess like” on hand, I am not going to spend money on that shit. We have a nice school dress that she can wear I guess). It is noted to be a “model and princess party”. Oy. I find parties like this confining to the imagination, and as a parent, frivolous (more than I think a birthday party is to begin w/).
The second is from a girl we met while we were still living in the Army’s Hotel here. Her invitation invites us to come to the Arts and Crafts building (some Army bases have these, it seems) to make and paint your own pottery. I thought this was a great idea, allowing the kids to get creative and a little messy. They get to make something tangible and uniquely their own to take home.
I am sure I could say a lot about the concept of throwing a “model” or “princess” themed party for a bunch of little girls. My head is so full right now of reasons why we should not hold up models as the ideal to strive for that I am sure I couldn’t choose one upon which to elaborate. As far as princess goes there is myriad of reasons why I object to the idealization and glamorization of the pink-puke Disney crap.
What I will say is that I commend the parents (I have only met the second girl’s father b/c the mother was still in the States when we all arrived) of the second girl for this pottery making idea. It’s cheap (you only cover a basic fee for materials), it’s expressive, and it helps the children reach into that place inside them where the magic happens. The part of them that is creative and yearning to emerge, which I am convinced that all children possess if it is fostered well. It’s also a little messy, which is for some reason delightful.
I am going to RSVP both parties, b/c I want The Kid to socialize w/ her new friends. I won’t, however feel bad that the fact that I can not yet navigate the stairs to the pedestrian walkway b/t here and the military village might prevent me from actually taking her to the first party (the second I can take a cab from our house to).
How do other parents out there handle these issues? How do we continue to foster our good progressive and feminist ideals to our children when we are bombarded w/ princess and model parties?
And what is the name of that really kick ass book about the princess who decided she didn’t need a stinky ol’ prince anyway? That would make a great gift. ;) ETA: Found it! (And thanks to BFP for linking to Indiebound, and letting me know there was an Amazon alternative!)













Just a quick note – The Paper Bag Princess is another excellent who-needs-a-prince-anyway princess book.
OH! yes I am familiar w/ the Paper Bag Princess…we love that one.
I just heard about the other and couldn’t remember the title. But yes, the PBP would be great as well.
have I told you how much I love you for giving anti-prince books to the princess girl. Seriously, massively love you.
That’s an awesome way to be proactive and feminist! I have two friends that are pregnant and I want positive and feminist gifts to give to both of them. I thought of “free to be you and me” but that’s it. I will look into the princess books if they find out they are having girls
Not to be offensive or rude,
but i am totally against sexism,
but i love pink and dresses and things like that, but at the same time i love camoflouge and blue and fighting games, so i think i would choose the princess party, i also dont think that it is offensive at all.
Hannah, this is a really old post…try reading around a bit to get an idea of thing here.
There is nothing wrong w/ liking those things specifically. It is the idea that being a model or a princess s somehow the embodiment of all things girl…and I find it disturbing when supermodels are starving themselves to death to look like women they can never be (because they are all airbrushed anyway). The Disney princess thing is another ball of wax, involving a ton of condescension to little girls and a whole slew of mixed signals about what a young girl should set her goals to be. There is more to life than hoping a Prince will whisk you away.
Good luck with your blog and with the teen years. It gets better than this, I promise.